Forget IDV: Vanguard’s VYMI Returned 29% in a Year While Charging Just 0.07%

VYMI beats IDV with a 29% one-year return versus 26% for IDV, while charging just 0.07% compared to IDV's 0.50% expense ratio.

IDV's 5.1% yield tops VYMI's 3.4%, but its high-yield screen overweights stressed payers and slow-growth utilities, dragging total return.

In a taxable account, stop reinvesting IDV distributions and redirect new contributions to VYMI to shift exposure without triggering a capital gains event.

Read More: Learn 7 secret wealth tips high net worth investors use that most investors miss (sponsor)

If you own the iShares International Select Dividend ETF (CBOE:IDV), the pitch was straightforward: concentrated exposure to roughly 100 of the highest-yielding developed-market dividend payers outside the U.S., wrapped in a familiar iShares ticker. That formula still delivers a rich income stream, and IDV holders have watched the fund benefit from a strong year for European and Asia-Pacific dividend names. But the fund carries a cost structure and a concentration profile that a much cheaper, broader Vanguard alternative quietly beats on total return, and the gap is wide enough that longtime IDV owners should look at what they are actually paying for.

IDV tracks the Dow Jones EPAC Select Dividend Index and concentrates its book in about 100 established payers in the U.K., Australia, France, Italy, and Spain, with a heavy tilt toward financials and utilities. That concentration is intentional: by screening for the highest yielders, IDV produced a trailing 12-month distribution of $2.28 per share against a current price of $44.26, a trailing yield near 5.1%. For income-first investors, that headline number is why the fund sits in the portfolio.

How do you continue to grow a seven-figure portfolio in retirement? The last thing you want is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.

Learn seven strategies high net worth investors use with new report: The Seven Secrets of High Net Worth Investors from Fisher Investments. Get your guide here (sponsor)

The problem is the expense ratio. IDV charges 0.50% per year, verified against the fund's August 31, 2026 prospectus. On a $50,000 position, that is $250 in fund fees every year, whether the fund rises or falls. Combined with a concentrated roster and heavy sector tilts, IDV's index construction has produced a one-year total return of 25.72%, respectable in absolute terms, but trailing a broader competitor built for the same job.

The swap candidate is the Vanguard International High Dividend Yield Index Fund ETF (NASDAQ:VYMI), the international sibling of Vanguard's well-known domestic high-yield fund. VYMI charges 0.07%, verified from Vanguard's June 2026 fact sheet. That is a 43 basis point annual fee gap in VYMI's favor, or roughly $215 saved per year on a $50,000 position, compounding for as long as the money stays invested.

Fee savings are only the starting point of the case. VYMI spreads capital across a far broader roster of dividend payers rather than screening down to only the top 100 yielders. Over the last year, that construction delivered a total return of 29.2%, ahead of IDV by several percentage points while sitting on $20 billion in net assets, an AUM base that keeps trading spreads tight and tracking clean.

IDV holders should weigh a real tradeoff here. VYMI's trailing yield sits near 3.4%, backed by $3.60 in trailing 12-month distributions against a $104.79 share price. IDV pays more current income. If your only measure is the yield line, IDV wins that box. What VYMI wins on is total return, which is what actually funds withdrawals and grows the portfolio. Higher-yield screens tend to overweight financially stressed payers and slow-growth utilities, and the last 12 months are a live example: IDV's richer distribution did not translate into a richer total return.

In a tax-advantaged account (IRA, 401k rollover, Roth), the swap is mechanical. Sell IDV, buy VYMI, no tax consequence. In a taxable account, first check your cost basis. If you bought IDV meaningfully below $44.26, a full swap triggers a capital gain, and the fee savings may take years to overcome the tax bill. A common middle path is to stop reinvesting IDV distributions and redirect new contributions to VYMI, letting the position shift over time without a taxable event.

IDV works as designed. It is simply a narrow, more expensive vehicle, in a category where a broader, cheaper option has produced better total returns while doing the same job of paying international dividends. If you own IDV for the yield line specifically and accept concentration risk, staying put is defensible. If you own it as your core international income sleeve, VYMI's 0.07% fee, broader roster, and stronger one-year total return make it the more efficient way to hold the same exposure.

How do you continue to grow a seven-figure portfolio in retirement? The last thing you want is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.

Learn seven strategies high net worth investors use with new report: The Seven Secrets of High Net Worth Investors from Fisher Investments. Get your guide here (sponsor)

Contact editorial@247wallst.com for any questions or corrections.